This is our favorite pizza spot. The pizza is great and not over priced. The workers are polite and professional and bring your pizza to the table if you eat in, and box up your leftovers and they’re not even waiters!
– Belinda Foss Hall

Very good pizza when we are back in Wilmington will be heading back. Came from Myrtle Beach when a good friend told us about the pizza. Just like home Long Island N.Y.
– James Carpenter

Best calzone I’ve had since I left New Jersey, stuffed with ricotta and mozzarella ham and mushrooms, nice crispy crust golden brown. Can’t go wrong here.
– Donna Baker Loichle

Great pizza, best in Wilmington and some of the best I’ve had in general.
– Greg McGonigal

Love love love this place! My grandma and I eat here for lunch quite often! Pizza is always hot and fresh and staff is great! My favorite pizza place!
– Jasmine Brown

This is by far the best pizza I have ever had. I ordered a 12′ with anchovies. It was hot and the service time was great. Also they aren’t skimpy with the anchovies like most place’s. If your ever passing through stop here for the best pizza you will ever eat.
– Sammy Smith

This is my first time dining at Brooklyn pizza and it was great. I am not really a pizza fan so I got the steak Stromboli and loved it. We will definitely be back.
– Troy Fredell

We’ve been going to Brooklyn for several years and have tried just about everything on the menu from sandwiches to Pizza to some of the most delicious entrees! We have truly never had bad service or bad food. It’s always been absolutely the best of both!
– Kelly Walker

It’s the people and the pizza that keep us coming back for more. Love the owners and the management. Even on busy nights like the Friday before Easter! Pleasant drivers and Amazing pizza!
– Paul Davis

I worked at Brooklyn 15 years ago and the food is just as good today!! Waiting for them to come to my door any minute now.
– Brandon Luck

Great pizza! If you are just looking for great food and no over the top atmosphere, this is the place to eat. I am not a fan of NY style pizza, but this was delicious. Friendly service and perfectly cooked pizza!
– Will W.

I am from New York and this is the closest thing to NY pizza in Wilmington. Delicious! Always on point 🙂
– Maria N.

Outstanding food and value. We had chicken parm and chicken francese. This is our go to place when at Wrightsville Beach.
– Sid A.

This place is Awesome. If you like authentic New York pizza then this is definitely your closet bet in Wilmington. Really cheap by the slice and their calzone is to die for. They have great daily deals. Love this place!!! Will not go anywhere else for pizza.
– Andrea V.

Ok they’re getting better with realistic times for when your order is ready and it’s one of if not the best pizza in town.
– Scott L.

If you like authentic NY Style Pizza you have to try Brooklyn Pizza in Wilmington, NC. Anthony worked in his dad’s pizzeria while growing up in Brooklyn NY. You can’t get more authentic New York than that! Crisp crust. Tangy sause and the best cheese. Mmmmm.
– Randy L.

While vacationing in Wilmington we found Brooklyn Pizza Co.. Probably one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had! Super delicious food with a friendly staff! Will be going back.
– Jessica Kennedy

Love the pizza here. Closest to home I’ve found since moving to Wilmington from Long Island NY. I’ve noticed a slip in the customer service however in the last couple years. Not as friendly anymore.
– Nick Atkins

I’ve been going here for almost 10 years. They have friendly staff and the price is good for the quality of the food. Best pizza in Wilmington!
– Marvin Green Jr

Originally from Jersey so I know pizza! Been in Brunswick County for 10 years and FINALLY found pizza that reminded me of home! Took my Mom and son today and they gave it 2 thumbs up! We’ll DEFINITELY see you again Brooklyn Pizza…
– Tyran Wade

This is the BEST pizza in Wilmington. Their lasagna is also very good.
– David M Fogleman

I can’t say I’ve ever eaten in NYC but this place is top shelf.
– Charles Barden

Best pizza in town! I’ve been ordering pizza from Brooklyn’s for years. Never a bad pizza, always outstanding!
– Holly Banks Foster

Been coming here since I was a baby, this place has the best pizza ever. Every time I come here I feel like I’m in New York.
– Courtney Da Corgi

This pizza comes super close to NY pizza. Best I had out here in NC.
– Maureen Kepler Williams

Best pizza in Wilmington area, great crust and sauce.
– Rocco D’Aprile

Delicious cheese pie! Nothing like having a great NY Pizza in the south…lets go YANKEES!
– Hans Malloy

Great pizza! Wish they sold their shirts! Very nice staff.
– Sue Kinkade

When a slice of pizza is bigger than your face, it has to be good. This pizza is fantastic. Every time I visit this place it is busy. Sign of good pizza!
– Jen C.

I have eaten at every pizzeria in town and Brooklyns is by far the best. Sauce is really good. White pizza is delicious. Garlic knots are great. Try the jack Daniels buffalo wings. They are outstanding.
– Robert G.

Pizza has been the best in Wilmington for years, nothing else comes close.
– Roscoe E.

Finally made it here and this is as close to New York style thin crust pizza that I’ve tasted since moving to Wilmington. Had the fresh basil and tomato with mozzarella. Great choice and was yummy. They were busy but service was excellent and wait was minimal. Another visit will be in my future.
– Lisa C.

Excellent delivery Pizza! The NY style crust and great tasting sauce combine to create a hot, fresh pizza no one would expect to be delivered to a home in NC. Service was great from initial call to delivery. Highly recommend.
– Tom W.

If you are from the North and miss the real deal, here it is! Best pizza in town.
– Arty A.

Best pizza outside of New York, great food, great service, large portions.
– Linda Guastella-Quagliariello

Awesome Pizza great service worth the trip! Would highly recommend to anyone in the area…
– Donna L Kerr

Our favorite pizza place when we lived in Wilmington – miss it so much!
– Polly Rhoad Dowd

The owners are amazing people and the food is incredible!!! 5 stars all the way!
– Kevin Sandera

Great pie! So good, while staying at Topsail we drove to the Hampstead location twice in three days. Cheesy goodness….love!
– Laura Browning

5 stars for their 18 inch margarita pizza. Fresh garlic, basil and thinly sliced tomato with fresh moz on a giant thin crust. Perfection. I don’t know anything about anything else on their menu and I don’t need to! If you are a margarita pizza connoisseur you will not be disappointed.
– Anna B.

Delicious NY pizza right in Wilmington! My husband is Italian from NJ, and I’m a New Yorker, so this means something! Forgetta about the rest!
– Susan D.

Best NY style pizza in Wilmington. Make sure you try a slice of their “grandma” pizza, which is a Sicilian cut topped with chunky tomato, basil, fresh mozzarella, and garlic. Delicious.
– Tim B.

Being a guy from NJ, I miss good thin crust pizza living in the south. These guys remedy that perfectly with delicious New York / New Jersey style pizza. By the slice is cheap, and the knots are good. Get two orders and thank me later.
– James M.

Love this place! You can eat in, get take out or get delivery. Everything I’ve ever ordered has been great.
– Shannon S.

Great pizza. The grandma slice is one of my favorites. Good group of employees eager to help and quick to serve up a slice. Will definitely be back
– Joe E.

Great NYC style pizza in NC! Love that they offer pizza slices and pies, variety of toppings, and other Italian entrees. It was super busy when we visited – great testament to great food and service!
– D W.

We eat here at least 3 times a month. The in restaurant service is always amazing and the delivery service is always fast, hot and reliable. We’ve been eating Brooklyn Pizza Co at this location for 4 years now and have never ever had a wrong order or inferior service. Out of town relatives always request this pizzeria when they visit. Never disappointed!
– Kathy C.

BEST FOOD EVER. Excellent cheese pizza, chicken wings, lasagna, garlic knots… Excellent everything. The pizza is the biggest pizza I’ve ever seen. Must eat here!
– Sarah D.

This place is amazing! Usually Italian and NY style pizzas do ring up to about 20$ for just 1 large, but it is well worth it here. Small place but big taste! It’s delicious and recommend it to any pizza lover!
– Jamie S.

It is with a great deal of joy and enthusiasm that I can state, for the record, that I have found the best pizza south of the north end! Brooklyn pizza is delicious, nothing like the poorly discussed corrugated cardboard that most local establishments have tried to pass off as pizza.
– Mike M.